Warning back in 2006- hughes syndrome
Call for tests to avoid misdiagnosis of MS
Hazel Edwards was wrongly diagnosed with multiple sclerosis and ended up paralysed in a wheelchair
By Roger Highfield, Science Editor
12:01AM BST 31 Jul 2006
Two decades after a British doctor discovered a syndrome that can easily be mistaken for multiple sclerosis, he warns today that hundreds of people may still be wrongly diagnosed because simple tests are not offered as a matter of routine.
The rheumatologist Dr Graham Hughes reported in the British Medical Journal in 1983 that he had identified the syndrome - now called Hughes Syndrome - that resulted in blood becoming sticky, leading to potentially dangerous blood clots.
Evidence has emerged that it could cause one in five recurrent miscarriages, as well as one in five strokes in younger people, and one in five DVTs (deep vein thromboses).
The good news is that, unlike multiple sclerosis (MS) - which affects 85,00 Britons - the syndrome can usually be treated with blood-thinning drugs such as aspirin and warfarin.
You might like:
Landslide victory for allies of ousted Thai leader in exit polls03 Jul 2011(Telegraph News)
Sir David Frost paid to promote Gaddafi03 Jul 2011(Telegraph News)
Prince William and Kate Middleton's royal tour of Canada and the US: day three as it happened02 Jul 2011(Telegraph News)
From the Web
FORM THE WEB
7 Exercises for Low-Back Pain24 Apr 2011(Lifescript.com)
Wife Gets Cancer, Husband Gets Fired16 Jun 2011(AOL Jobs)
15 Countries That Consume The Most Alcohol09 Mar 2011(CNBC)
You might like:
Oscar-winner Glenda Jackson calls time on her political career23 Jun 2011(Telegraph News)
Thousands of Parkinson's disease sufferers wrongly diagnosed, report claims12 Jun 2011(Telegraph News)
Heart disease risk 'increases for children who are inactive'12 Jun 2011(Telegraph News)
From the Web
FORM THE WEB
Deborah Norville on Living with Rheumatoid Arthritis10 Aug 2009(Lifescript.com)
Anti-cholesterol Drug Lipitor® Recalled01 Dec 1969(Healthcommunities.com)
The 25 Greatest Action-Adventure Movies Of All Time01 Dec 1969(BuzzFeed)
"It is still totally under-recognised," says Dr Hughes, now a professor at the London Lupus Centre. He estimates that five per cent of MS sufferers may be misdiagnosed.
For 26 years, John Simper, 60, from Ipswich, Suffolk, thought he would suffer the slow degeneration of MS, only to find he had Hughes Syndrome.
After the first blood tests came back positive a few weeks ago, he began campaigning for the test to become routine so some of the other estimated 150,000 people with the syndrome can be diagnosed. "The Government has to take notice," he said.
Few GPs are alert to the condition and lack of knowledge causes thousands of people to suffer needlessly, not only by thinking they have MS but, in the case of female sufferers, by having unnecessary miscarriages, said Prof Hughes.
He recommends that two simple blood tests be routinely offered to any MS patient who has suffered recurrent headaches, problems with clots such as DVT, a family history of autoimmune diseases, or who has had recurrent miscarriage.
Once the syndrome is diagnosed, aspirin, or anticoagulants such as heparin and warfarin, produces a dramatic reduction in symptoms in 80 per cent of patients, he said.
Dr Alasdair Coles, of Cambridge University, praised Prof Hughes's work, but said: "With modern techniques and careful inquiry, the number of people incorrectly diagnosed with MS is low."
The Department of Health was "not aware of any evidence that population screening would be beneficial".
Hazel Edwards, 48, of North Wales, was diagnosed with MS five years ago and ended up paralysed from the neck down.
She is now able to walk again, having been correctly diagnosed by Prof Hughes.
"As soon as I started warfarin, my memory improved and I found I could walk. I can drive and go to the gym. Prof Hughes and his team gave me back my life. But I feel very let down. My first symptoms of Hughes emerged 28 years ago."